Kevin Standlee (kevin_standlee) wrote,
Kevin Standlee
kevin_standlee

A Call for Dictatorship

Well, I'm probably exaggerating, but Paul Kincade's take on Awards in general and the Hugo Awards in particular, which is decently well-written and argued in my opinion, seems to think that allowing the members to have much say in how things are governed is a Bad Thing. He's right that the current system is maddeningly slow-moving and difficult to change. That's not really a bug; it's a deliberate design feature. We could be much more "efficient" if a a Single Strong Man or Secret Select Body made all of the decisions. But would that really be better?

Democracy is very inefficient. There seems, in my opinion, to be a longing from many people for a Strong Man to Be In Charge. Of course, I think the people longing for such things assume that the Strong Man would never make a decision with which those people disagree, which is part of the problem.
Tags: hugo awards, worldcon, wsfs
Subscribe

  • More Santa Fe Southern -- 1990s

    Also among the photos I scanned yesterday are two that Lisa took from a visit to the Santa Fe Southern Railroad. This time it was when she was…

  • Aboard the Santa Fe Southern -- in 2001

    Back in 2001 (or possibly in late 2000; we've lost track), Lisa and I went to Albuquerque: I flew; Lisa drove and collected me from the airport. She…

  • Short Trip Made Long

    Yesterday afternoon, when I got off work about 3 PM, Lisa and I went to Reno intending to get grocery shopping done at the newly-remodeled and…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 11 comments

  • More Santa Fe Southern -- 1990s

    Also among the photos I scanned yesterday are two that Lisa took from a visit to the Santa Fe Southern Railroad. This time it was when she was…

  • Aboard the Santa Fe Southern -- in 2001

    Back in 2001 (or possibly in late 2000; we've lost track), Lisa and I went to Albuquerque: I flew; Lisa drove and collected me from the airport. She…

  • Short Trip Made Long

    Yesterday afternoon, when I got off work about 3 PM, Lisa and I went to Reno intending to get grocery shopping done at the newly-remodeled and…