Kevin Standlee (kevin_standlee) wrote,
Kevin Standlee
kevin_standlee

More On Democracy

If you hold the opinion that having to pay to vote — i.e. pay membership dues to an organization in order to hold a franchise within that organization — isn't really "democracy," I'm going to have a very difficult time holding a coherent debate with you. If you claim that any voluntary organization that isn't a nation-state can't possibly be a "democracy," because all "democracies" allow everyone to vote, we're not on the same page. In fact, we may not even be in the same library.

My mind boggles at being told that voluntary organizations that govern themselves by democratic principles aren't "really" democracies, and that "real" democracy requires that anyone, anywhere, anytime, under any circumstances, must be allowed free, unfettered access to any franchise whatsoever. How in the world did people get this cockeyed viewing of how the world works?

If any of you happen to be reading this, I suggest you actually read Robert's Rules of Order Newly Revised, or at least the foreword, which is only about 25 pages long and explains the history of how Major (later General) Robert came to write a book on voluntary deliberative assemblies and governance structures. I consider Robert's to be the technical manual of democracy. If you think "democracy" is "everyone, anytime, anywhere, and always free, and never with any responsibility," then you've only been reading the sales brochures.
Tags: hugo award, politics, worldcon, wsfs
Subscribe

  • Bad Timing

    As I mentioned a few days ago, I made a big order of CPAP supplies. So of course just after it arrived, the vendor announced a big sale with savings…

  • Marking Time Again

    Lisa has hurt her back in some way, and I couldn't get to sleep last night, so there's nothing much to write about today. Getting extra sleep seems…

  • New Year Recovery

    Lisa and I attended parts of an fans-around-the-world New Year's Eve party. We joined in between Paris and London's NYE, and except for a period…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 25 comments

  • Bad Timing

    As I mentioned a few days ago, I made a big order of CPAP supplies. So of course just after it arrived, the vendor announced a big sale with savings…

  • Marking Time Again

    Lisa has hurt her back in some way, and I couldn't get to sleep last night, so there's nothing much to write about today. Getting extra sleep seems…

  • New Year Recovery

    Lisa and I attended parts of an fans-around-the-world New Year's Eve party. We joined in between Paris and London's NYE, and except for a period…