They did a pretty good job, getting the color scheme, the orange carpet, the general set design, etc. For some reason, it sounded like they used the actual theme music, but they used a remix of the "think" music that I'd never heard before and that I expect they composed just for this show. They were close, but not exactly matching, the typefaces and little details of the design from the original. Considering how many details they had to try and reproduce, I'm impressed. Like with all of the other shows they recreated in this series (except The Price is Right, for which the sets already exist), it seems like a heck of a lot of work to produce just one episode of the series.
I'm not sure why they used the Match Game '73 logo, including the '73. (That's a different version of the logo than what I'm showing as my user icon here and that we've adapted for use with Match Game SF.) I would have left the year off the logo entirely. Possibly this was because they were shooting to reproduce the exact '73 variation of the rules, which means they did not use the "Star Wheel" for the Celebrity Match, but allowed the contestant to select a panelist instead. On the other hand, they used the Match Game PM variation of three rounds in order to stretch the show out to an hour, so who knows? Maybe they didn't want to build the Star Wheel.
I think it was really great that in the #6 "Betty White" seat was... Betty White! The other celebrity choices seemed to fit their historical counterparts. In fact, I think that if they wanted to bring this game back, they could do worse than starting with this bunch. But they won't revive this show. Every attempt to revive it has failed, IMO because the show isn't nearly as edgy now as it was in the 1970s.
Still, it's pretty fun to play with the right panelists. I hope the chemistry clicks at Westercon. As it happens, yesterday, I bought a package of 500 large index cards for use by the panelists. We used up most of the cards that I had in stock during BayCon. I also, if I find the time, want to replace the "contestant score" and "panelist match" indicators with larger ones printed in color. Fingers crossed.