Log in

No account? Create an account
Kevin Standlee: Fandom Is My Way of Life
[Most Recent Entries] [Calendar View] [Friends View]

Saturday, March 31st, 2007

Time Event
Every Year, It's the Same Thing
So far, in my corner of the blogosphere where I've seen things:

1. The Hugo Awards are being given to fantasy works much too often.

2. You don't see many fantasy works nominated -- the Hugos are dominated by science fiction.

3. The Hugo Awards are much too elitist and snobby. You shouldn't have to pay $40 to vote.

4. The Hugo Awards are much too populist. They'll let anyone with $40 vote.

5. You have to lobby The Committee by casting "write-in" votes to make Them add the categories and nominees you want.

6. The Secret Masters of Fandom control the results, so it's hopeless to get Them to try and change anything.

7. It's terrible that not enough members of Worldcon are voting.

8. I'm a member of Worldcon, but I'm not eligible to vote because I haven't read enough.

9. It's a terrible shame that [Category] has the Same Old Usual Suspects again. They need to nominate someone new to shake things up.

10. It's a travesty, I tell you, that [Person] was nominated for [Category]! S/he is nowhere near [qualified in some way/fannish/professional] enough for it!

Yes, I exaggerate somewhat, but that's this gist of many of the arguments.

And I probably could say this every single year.

Edit, 11:35: Added a couple more points, and thanks to Cheryl for suggesting them.

Edit, 13:05: Added two more thanks to dsmoen's suggestion.

Current Mood: frustrated
Yes, And I Should Be God-Emperor While You're At It
In this comment on a blog where I'm having an exchange of e-mails is a sentence that (as I later say in my follow-on), sums up much of the negative experiences I have had in fandom:
Any decision I don't have full control over, I feel perfectly justified in criticising.

Current Mood: gobsmacked

<< Previous Day 2007/03/31
Next Day >>
San Francisco Science Fiction Conventions Inc.   About LiveJournal.com