Kevin Standlee (kevin_standlee) wrote,
Kevin Standlee

Change at the Top

As announced earlier today, Mary Robinette Kowal has agreed to chair DisCon III, the 2020 Worldcon. She was appointed to the position by the board of directors of DC3's parent non-profit corporation after William Lawhorn resigned a few days ago. Lawhorn's resignation came after the WSFS division manager and most of the Hugo Award Administration Subcommittee announced their resignations.

Linda Deneroff took over as WSFS division manager, and a new set of people agreed to join the Hugo Administration Subcommittee (HASC). The HASC is very important in the structure of a Worldcon, because while the Worldcon committee can create and appoint members to the HASC, it cannot fire them, and per Section 3.13 of the WSFS Constitution, the HASC's decisions regarding the administration of the Hugo Awards (i.e. voter eligibility, counting of votes, etc.) are irrevocable by the Worldcon Committee. That is, there is a "firewall" between the HASC and the rest of the convention, including the staging of the Hugo Awards ceremony. The HASC is the equivalent of the "independent accountants" who tally the votes for the Academy Awards.

Why am I harping on this? Because Mary Robinette is a finalist for the Hugo Awards this year. Because the HASC existed and had members on it before she joined the convention committee, her involvement in the Awards has no connection to the counting of the ballots and the selection of the winners. The staging of the ceremony is a different part of the convention, and is part of the convention Events division, which does report to the Chair. The vote counting and other administration of the Awards, however, is solely the responsibility of the Hugo Awards Subcommittee.

Another practical matter is that nobody on the HASC is eligible for a Hugo Award, but that's currently moot because the finalists have already been announced.

I do go on about this because I've already seen one person saying that it's a "bad look" to have a Hugo Award finalist chairing the convention, and who seemed to misunderstand the wording in the DisCon III announcement explaining the "firewall" between the Chair and the Hugo administrators.

The new members of the HASC have not been added to the DisCon III website yet, but I expect that to be updated soon. There will also soon be an update to the WSFS Business Meeting staff, because Linda resigned as Business Meeting chair when she agreed to take over managing the entire WSFS Division.
Tags: discon, worldcon, wsfs

  • Train Trip Houskeeping

    While reviewing the Worldcon Train Trip reservations (six reservations, seven total one-way legs) and looking through my Amtrak account, I realized…

  • Circle Completed

    This afternoon I decided to try to book the final leg of the Amtrak Circle Trip to Worldcon, that being the Los Angeles - San Jose run on New Year's…

  • TrainCon Scramble

    The smoke conditions were mostly unchanged today. Actually, it was slightly less funky than yesterday, with the AQI only 168, which is still…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.