Kevin Standlee (kevin_standlee) wrote,
Kevin Standlee

Americans More Charitable than British?

Cheryl pointed me at this news item:

Why do wealthy Americans donate so much to charity and rich Britons so little?

It's a shame that UK law doesn't recognize most of the classes of organizations that in the US would be "501(c)(3)" tax-exempt organizations to whom donations are considered charitable and also tax-deductible.

As I understand it, there is a British equivalent to what Americans call a "non-profit"* -- the "company limited by guarantee." Interaction's parent corporation (of which I am/was a director), UK 2005 Ltd., is such a legal entity. But it's not what the British call a "charity" and it's neither tax-exempt nor do donations to it get you a tax deduction.

Many American conrunning non-profit corporations like SFSFC, MCFI, SCIFI, etc. are both non-profit (or equivalent) corporations in their respective states and also 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organizations. There's a tendency to toss around "non-profit" and "501(c)(3)" and "charity" as if they were interchangeable terms, but they're not -- they all have subtle differences in meaning. In any event, 501(c)(3) organizations do not have to pay income tax on any profit (call it a "surplus" if the technical term for excess of revenues over expenses bothers you), and donations to such organizations are considered charitable donations, and you're allowed to deduct such donations from your income for the purpose of determining your personal income tax.

If UK law allowed the wide variety of organizations that can qualify for US 501(c)(3) status the same benefits as UK charities, I expect the British giving levels would be a bit higher.

*"Non-profit" and "not-for-profit" are functionally equivalent terms. I've never found any substantive legal distinction between them. It appears to me that the term one uses primarily comes down to the state in which you live and the semantic sensibilities of whoever drafted that state's constitution or corporate legislation. California's formal name for incorporated groups of this nature is "California Public Benefit Corporation."
Tags: 501(c)(3), charities, conrunning, non-profit

  • Defensible Space

    Yesterday stayed cloudy all day and (relatively) cool. I decided to tackle digging up the growth in the field next to the house, which, once it dries…

  • Train Trip Houskeeping

    While reviewing the Worldcon Train Trip reservations (six reservations, seven total one-way legs) and looking through my Amtrak account, I realized…

  • Circle Completed

    This afternoon I decided to try to book the final leg of the Amtrak Circle Trip to Worldcon, that being the Los Angeles - San Jose run on New Year's…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.