Kevin Standlee (kevin_standlee) wrote,
Kevin Standlee
kevin_standlee

Good Luck With That Theory

Arnie Katz ran my entire letter regarding Worldcon and the 2007 Hugo Award trophy in Vegas Fandom Weekly #102. He choose not to give a straight answer most of the questions I raised, which is his right -- he's the editor and can evade the questions if he so chooses -- but in response to my explanation about why "Worldcon" is a registered service mark which WSFS must defend in order to maintain its rights, he wrote:
No group of fans, no matter how well-intentioned and serious-minded, owns “worldcon.” (Note lowercase “w.”) The word “worldcon” has been part of the fannish lexicon for nearly 70 years and, while the World Science Fiction Convention may want to trademark a “Worldcon” logo or the like, the use of “worldcon” in lower-case in a context unrelated to the World Science Fiction Convention or to any similar convention is part of every fans cultural heritage.
The short answer to that assertion is, "You're wrong."

The slightly longer answer involves suggesting he apply that theory to Coke, Kleenex, Xerox, and the Oscar and see how well it works out. Just because those registered marks belong to Big Corporations and Worldcon happens to belong to an unincorporated literary society whose roots trace back to the same corner of fandom of your own doesn't mean it's any less true.
Tags: worldcon
Subscribe

  • Work Reorgs Large and Small

    First, the large one: XPO Logistics Announces Plan to Spin Off Logistics Segment to Its Shareholders. I have absolutely no inside information about…

  • Computer Assembly

    After getting the new Dell G7 working, on Sunday I disassembled my desk, cleaned, dusted, and vacuumed, and started putting things back together…

  • First New Computer in Twenty Years

    I haven't bought a truly new computer for roughly twenty years. For most of that time, I've taken advantage of my employer surplusing my work…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 17 comments

  • Work Reorgs Large and Small

    First, the large one: XPO Logistics Announces Plan to Spin Off Logistics Segment to Its Shareholders. I have absolutely no inside information about…

  • Computer Assembly

    After getting the new Dell G7 working, on Sunday I disassembled my desk, cleaned, dusted, and vacuumed, and started putting things back together…

  • First New Computer in Twenty Years

    I haven't bought a truly new computer for roughly twenty years. For most of that time, I've taken advantage of my employer surplusing my work…