Kevin Standlee (kevin_standlee) wrote,
Kevin Standlee
kevin_standlee

  • Mood:

Hugo Award® Reactions

I haven't posted anything here today, but that doesn't mean I've been silent, as there has been plenty of discussion of the just-released Hugo Award Nominations, and I've been commenting on those, here on LJ, on the SMOFS e-mail list, and elsewhere. I can't really point to all of it, but it's been interesting to me to try and follow as much as I can.

Some people have been dismayed that two at-Worldcon presentations got nominated for Best Dramatic Presentation. Well, I wouldn't be surprised if a larger proportion of the nominating electorate (the union of the 2005 and 2006 Worldcon members) had seen those two works than have seen any of the others, including those Doctor Who episodes. Not that I expect either of them to win, of course, delighted as I am that they were nominated.

There has been the usual discussions that -- to exaggerate somewhat -- this year's nomination show that Science Fiction is Doomed, and other complaints that sort of boil down to "the Hugos don't reflect my personal preferences, so they're obviously flawed." But I've come to expect that. After all, people have been reporting the Death of Science Fiction (and the Death of Fandom) since before I was born. And most of the time, many of the Hugo Award nominations (or the winners) do not reflect my personal tastes either. So what? They reflect the tastes of a bunch of members of WSFS, and on the whole, it seems to produce relatively high-quality results. It's unreasonable of me to expect the rest of the electorate to change their opinions just for my sake.

In several places, people continue to complain that there are too many categories, and thereby the awards are cheapened. Well, personally, if there were Hugo Awards for written fiction in ten-thousand word bands up to 250,000 words, I'd tend to agree; however, I do not see how the presence of a Best Fan Artist Hugo Award makes the Best Novel Hugo Award less valuable, any more than the Oscar® for Best Costume Design cheapens the Academy Award® for Best Picture. Perhaps someone can explain this to me in a way that my poor feeble brain can comprehend.
Tags: hugo awards
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 3 comments